The top 5 West Virginia high school (Fast-Pitch) softball programs since 1970 are:
Wheeling Central Catholic Maroon Knights - 12 championships
(Tie) Sissonville Indians - 7 championships
(Tie) Buffalo (Putnam) Bison - 7 championships
(Tie) Shady Spring Tigers - 6 championships
(Tie) Hurricane Redskins - 6 championships
(Tie) Chapmanville Tigers - 6 championships
(Tie) Cabell Midland Knights - 6 championships
(Tie) Hoover (Clendenin) Huskies - 6 championships